Is Calvinism a Different Gospel?

Question

Dear Dr. Stratton,

Why do you spend so much time arguing with other Christians about free will? Why do you spend so much time arguing against Calvinism? We are all on the same team. We all worship the same God. We all share the same gospel. 

While these topics are very interesting and fun to think about, do they really make that much difference at the end of the day? 

- Jared

Dr. Tim's Response

Thank you for the question, Jared. I fear that answering it will make some of my friends quite angry. Be that as it may, I am committed to truth, and what I am about to communicate is -- I sincerely believe -- the truth and nothing but the truth.

So help me, God! 

The reason why this issue is so important -- and not some odd and abstract peripheral theological view -- is because although we all use the same words when sharing the gospel, after one looks under the hood (as it were), one will quickly see that the view Calvinists espouse is, quite frankly, a radically different understanding of the gospel than the one most Christians have in mind when sharing the good news with non-believers.

Notable Calvinist scholar, Matthew J. Hart, is clear: “Calvinists . . . are theological determinists. They hold that God causes every contingent event, either directly . . . or indirectly.” Since human thoughts and states of belief are contingent events, this means that God, according to Calvinistic determinism, causes each and every thought and belief, including all of our false and evil beliefs. In his work titled The Providence of God, Paul Helm -- who many consider to be the world's leading Calvinist philosopher -- explains where our thoughts come from according to his Calvinistic view:

“Not only is every atom and molecule, every thought and desire, kept in being by God, but every twist and turn of each of these is under the direct control of God. He has not, as far as we know, delegated that control to anyone else.”

If these scholars are correct in their assessment of Calvinism (that Calvinism entails exhaustive determinism), then I contend that Calvinism -- the view that God determines all things about humanity -- promotes the following incorrect views:

1- A low view of God.

As I've explained elsewhere, if exhaustive divine determinism is true, then God is a deity of deception and an untrustworthy source of theological beliefs. 

2- A low view of God's word.

Based on the transfer of trust principle, if God is an untrustworthy source of theological beliefs, then why should we trust a book authored by a deity of deception that is full of theological statements you are supposed to believe?  If God is untrustworthy, so is a book he inspired. Thus, appealing to Bible verses or to the original Greek does nothing to escape this presupposed false and low view of God and His word. 

3- A low view of man.

Man does not have the ability to reason free from antecedent conditions which are sufficient to necessitate all of his thoughts and beliefs. Man is nothing but a caused cause or a passive cog (a puppet) who is always tethered to prior deterministic forces. 

Thus, on this view, man does not have the active power to infer better beliefs in a deliberative circumstance. He is merely a passive cog who is determined (by something or someone else) to believe truth or to believe falsities.  

4- A low view of sin.

The definition of sin is to "miss the mark." However, there is no missing the mark if God determines all things about humanity. Everyone always hits the mark perfectly -- exactly as God determined. 

5- A low view of the gospel.

This, in my opinion, is the deal-breaker. Calvinism is a low view of the gospel. The gospel literally means "the good news." Here's how Christianity has traditionally understood this "good news" with the help of the G.O.S.P.E.L. acronym:

G – God--a perfect being--created all people to be in an eternal loving relationship with Him (that is the objective purpose of life – this is why humanity exist).(Psalm 100:3)

O – Our sins (emphasis on "our") infect us and separate us from God (like oil and water, necessary perfection and infection do not mix). (Romans 3:23)

S – Sins cannot be removed by good deeds (there’s nothing we as infected people can do about it – we need a miracle). (Isaiah 64:6)

P – Paying the price for sin, Jesus died and rose again (this is that miracle – Jesus paid it all). (Romans 5:8)

E – Everyone who freely trusts in Christ alone – and has not rejected His offer of love and grace – has eternal life (John 3:16).

L – Life with Jesus starts now and lasts forever (to infinity . . . and beyond). (John 10:28)

But Calvinism literally preaches a different gospel. Consider Paul's words in Galatians 1: 6-8:

"6 I am astonished that you are so quickly deserting him who called you in the grace of Christ and are turning to a different gospel— 7 not that there is another one, but there are some who trouble you and want to distort the gospel of Christ. 8 But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed."

Here's the Calvinist's different G.O.S.P.E.L.*:

G* - God created a few people to be with him. Most people were created for the specific purpose of eternal suffering in Hell.

Right off the bat, we see that this is not the Gospel message that has been preached in Scripture or through the history of the Christian Church. At the least, it's a radically different message than what most Christians have had in mind over the past 2,000 years when sharing the good news.

It gets worse . . .

O* – Our separation from God is caused and determined by God.

Let that sink in! 

S* – Sins are illusory.

As noted above, no one ever misses the mark (the definition of sin), but everyone does exactly what God determines us to do. Every arrow hits the bulls eye. 

P* – Paying the price for what God caused and determined all people to do, Jesus died and rose again.

At least Calvinists and non-Calvinist Christians all affirm the historical resurrection (but so do Mormons). 

E* – Everyone who God determines to go to heaven goes to heaven; everyone else (the majority of humanity) is determined to suffer in the fires of hell.

Unless, of course, the Calvinist affirms universalism and argue that allpeople are given irresistible grace and determined to go to heaven. Calvinists can also affirm annihilationism and contend that eternal separation from God is still determined by God (so the problem still remains), but there is no eternal conscious suffering. Both views are typically rejected by most Calvinists. 

L* – Life in hell lasts forever.

Does this sound like "good news"? No, in fact, it's horrible news to the vast majority of humanity. Calvinism is not the message of Christianity. It is a distorted understanding of the gospel that ought to be rejected by Christ followers. 

For a deeper dive into each of these topics and important related issues please watch this video. 

Stay reasonable (Isaiah 1:18),

Dr. Tim Stratton

Notes

 Matthew J. Hart, “Calvinism and the Problem of Hell,” in Calvinism and the Problem of Evil, edited by David E. Alexander and Daniel M. Johnson (Eugene, OR: Pickwick Publications, 2016), 248. Hart notes that Paul Helm—the leading Calvinistic philosopher today—is a theological determinist (Hart, “Calvinism,” 248n1). 

 Paul Helm, The Providence of God, Contours of Christian Theology, edited by Gerald Bray (Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 1993), 22, Logos.